| file under: vision of hope, peace in the Middle East, Demonstrations, billionaires for peace | 4 Mar 2011 4:24 PM |
| Doing Justice to the Martyrs | Posted by Nissim Dahan |
It's one thing to bring about a revolution; it's quite another to bring about revolutionary change.
There are people dying, even as we speak, on the streets of the Middle East. Mohammed Bouazizi of Tunisia set himself on fire, and in one fell swoop, set the entire region ablaze. But to what end?
Like Martin Luther King, the man on the street has a dream. And his dream is not all that difficult to fathom. He wants the dignity of a decent job, and the freedom to live his life as he wishes. Are these aspirations in the cards for him, or will his dream be left in the dust, in the flurry of competing agendas?
One can only imagine what must be happening now behind closed doors, in the halls of political power; what promises are being made; what deals are being cut. When the dust settles, will the voices of the dead be heard?
Several possibilities come to mind. The old guard may find a way to reassert its grip on power, only in a new guise. Alternatively, the ideological extremists, who believe what they want to believe, could use the ballot box to gain control, only to impose a new regime of oppressive rule. Iran, after all, enjoyed a few months of democratic rule, after the fall of the Shah, only to usher in the Ayatollahs, who had a different idea in mind. One man, one vote, one time. Or so the motto goes. And finally, although there are no guarantees, it may actually be possible, this time around, to institute revolutionary change, the change that gives life to the aspirations of the people, and that does justice to the legacy of the dead.
What can be done to give substance to the hopes of the people? Three things. First, we should recognize the opportunity that exists for meaningful change. Second, we should embrace a vision which allows us to take advantage of that opportunity. And third, we should find a mechanism that allows us to give substance to the vision. In this way, we can finally make real what is now only a dream.
The opportunity that exists for real change in the Middle East comes from the fact that many of the key players are beginning to worry about the same kinds of things, and may actually need one another for a change, to stave off these very common existential threats. "The enemy of my enemy is my friend." For example, many Arab leaders worry about two things in particular: the threat from a nuclear Iran, and the threat from the man on the street. These common threats could point to common interests, what I call a mosaic of mutual self-interest, which could in turn be used to create a strategic/economic alliance between the Arab states, Israel, the U.S., and Europe. The alliance will focus primarily on two things: providing security for the region and creating good paying jobs; jobs which grow our economies, jobs which protect the environment, and jobs which weaken the hold of extremist thinking.
What sort of a vision will be required to take advantage of the opportunity that exists for real change? It should be a Vision of Hope for the Middle East, a vision of Peace, Prosperity and Freedom. It will be a vision which puts together all the pieces of a possible solution to our most intractable problems-the Economy, the Environment and Extremism-which packages those pieces in the most attractive way possible, and which allows us to sell that package to the man on the street. It will be a vision which inspires a sense of hope, and which delivers on that promise by giving everyone in the region a place at the table, a stake in his or her future. And it will be a vision which is complete, in that it addresses all the needs and aspirations of the people, from every point of view possible.
And what mechanism can best give substance to a Vision of Hope? Certainly, political leaders will be needed, who recognize the needs and aspirations of the people, and who know how to translate those intangibles into hard realities. But in addition, and perhaps even more importantly, business leaders will be needed as well, Billionaires for Peace, who will work behind the scenes to push the peace process forward, and to revitalize the entire region with good paying jobs, moderate candidates and requisite institutions. These visionaries will put in place a new model for the Middle East, a model that inspires a sense of hope, and that delivers on that promise.
More than any other group, it is perhaps the business community which is best positioned, most qualified, and most inclined to turn the Middle East around, and to do justice to the memory of the dead, by giving life to the aspirations of the living.

written by GABE1, March 06, 2011
written by GABE1, March 08, 2011
I am also intrigued at people asking others to open up their wallets and pour money down the toilet so that we can accomplish a peace(whatever that means). The Middle East has been awash with money from the USA, UNWRA, The EU as well as joint venture projects that are non-governmental and yet we have no peace or even a semblance of accountability for that money.
As a matter of interest Nissim, how much have you invested in the Middle East and I mean other than in the stock market-IN OIL?
With the population growth and its jihadist agenda the Middle East currently is a funnel that will siphon vast amounts of money that will accomplish ZERO, ZILCH KLUM, NADA-In short NOTHING.
So far you have not persuaded me or even made a dent in my thinking and as an economist and accountant, I am not persuaded and neither will any millionaire or billionaire.
Yo are engaging in wishful thinking and nothing more.
written by GABE1, March 09, 2011
When in Paris, I was told by one of my colleagues, that politics is on par with prostitution and the body goes to the highest bidder. There is no one that is leading this so called "peoples revolt" and within a short period of time it will be business as usual. Lots of smoke but too few visuals.
You are wrong. The way to go is to bring in birth control as China did. Look what they accomplished. From starvation to prosperity. It is not the system that we must look at but rather at the religious system and the politics of the womb.It will not overwhelm Israel but rather kill the Arabs as it is not sustainable.
You keep missing this completely and all you believe in is that money can solve all the ills. That is a fallacy.
written by GABE1, March 10, 2011
I am anxious to know whether you are putting your money where your mouth is or is it simply platitudes as practiced on that MEWAR site.
I have given you self help realistic solutions, but you are ignoring any reply to these and just continues on the same dead end topic.
written by GABE1, March 10, 2011
The Saudis had a chance to help the economies of their brethren since the 1920's yet they failed to do so. Human nature being what it is they will not do any different now. There is no money to be made in the Muslim world and so they will stay away. In clan societies, members of a clan are paramount.
Just like I sympathized with the Unions ,so I sympathize with your viewpoint and feel sorry for the poor of Egypt. As i told you before, my wife is from Egypt and I visited there and found the people very friendly. But no matter how I may want to, I cannot help any of them or even the poor in Israel. That is a function of government and luckily Israel has a good economy and does OK even with the mini depression that we had.
I do however take umbrage with your suggestion that equates Arab fanaticism with other religious fanaticism. Other religious fanatics are not urging murder, suicides and genocide. That my friend is the most idiotic statement that I have heard so far from you.
I gave you two solutions that are the answer. China is a good example of one and Europe an example of the other.
Money is not the solution and you seem to be flogging that same dead horse. The USA should give know how aid instead of military aid. You know Israel is very active in giving agricultural aid to Africa and South America and could very well help the Arab States in the Middle East if the climate was better and there would be peace. I know you think its a chicken and egg scenario, but peace is not dependent on Israel but rather on the Arab states.
BTW: Israel or the USA cannot change the players in Egyptian elections, no matter what anyone thinks.
written by GABE1, March 10, 2011
written by GABE1, March 12, 2011
You and your friends at MEWAR are simply DISGUSTING.
Now lets see how you wiggle your way out of this massacre yet again.
written by GABE1, March 13, 2011
I FEEL DISGUST FOR YOUR PSEUDO LEFTIST ORIENTATIONS THAT HAS IN FACT OVERTAKEN ANY GOOD JUDGMENT THAT YOU MAY HAVE HAD. MY WIFE WOULD NEVER CONDONE SUCH ACT EITHER SILENTLY OR OVERTLY. BUT I GUESS YOU BOTH ARE.
PS: I WILL BET THAT YOU ARE NOT EVEN TRYING TO COLLECT MONEY FOR THESE POOR ORPHANS. LOGIC AND REASON GONE SOUTH.
written by GABE1, March 13, 2011
Being disgusted is just not good enough anymore as this has been occurring in Palestine(Israel) since at least 1929 and in Europe for a long time. We must speak up and challenge the terror Rats and their antisemite allies such as you have on MEWAR- Basil and Sussan and Oliver and others. Have you noticed how they manage to kill off any opposition while we just meekly go along with them. That Nissim is my rage because they are the ones who are contributing to that murderous massacre.
What is it about "logic" that scares Jews to assert their rights? Have we lived so long amongst the gentiles that even when we come home after 2000 years we still feel that we must obey our masters elsewhere.
Your idea has never worked and will not work. You have assumed the mantle of your "cousins keeper" and teacher and mentor. You have missed the fact that they do not want you to be either these or even here on earth amongst them and certainly not in the Middle East.
Give me a time when this has not been the fact.
You know that I have a degree in Economics and Accountancy but what I did not tell you that like you I also have a degree in Law and have consulted on commercial law for Builders and Landlords and Developers for the past 25 years. I also have a degree in psychology.
In the 60's we were experimenting with social engineering and some of your current theories were tried in the Human Resources field as well as in the realm of Juvenile behaviour and laws thereof. I can tell you that these experiments failed miserably.
A pedophile cannot be cured neither can a murderer with no conscience. In either case either incarceration for life or a death sentence will stop them. When a dog tastes blood you must put it down and the same applies to terrorists. You do not arrest them, you eliminate them, period.
As for military means, it is a fallacy that Israel has tried the military route. It never happened and if tried without the military's hands being tied the war against terror can be won. Look into this and you will see that I am right.
written by GABE1, March 13, 2011
I am currently semi retired.
written by GABE1, March 14, 2011
Public support has nothing to do with poverty or social standing of the terrorists as evidenced by the 9/11 perpetrators or even El Azarqawi. All were well to do educated people with lots of support amongst the common man.
Revolutionaries throughout history have come from the upper classes who wanted to help the poor but in the Middle East we have the upper classes wanting to help bring their religious order to bear and maybe even bring back the glory days of their religion while killing and maiming the unbelievers.
written by GABE1, March 15, 2011
PEACE, PEACE, PEACE!!!!!!!
WE WILL HAVE PEACE EVEN IF IT KILLS US
written by GABE1, March 16, 2011
What contacts have so far been made with that "common man" whoever he may be and how many "common man" must we reach to accomplish this task. Will the "new" leadership be made up of this "common man" or will they just be recycled failed politicians who did not manage to line their pockets last time.
Once you identify that "common man" and that "common man leadership" please feel free to call me and I will join you at my cost to talk to them and see what they need to make a peaceful, long lasting transition necessary.
UNTIL THAN I prefer to be a REALIST to your DREAM.
JUST AN OBSERVATION.
Policies and priorities and interests change with time and generations even in Democratic countries. China and Russia were once friends and are now bitter enemies. Israel and Iran and Israel and Turkey were once friends.
Alliances shift with the times and need of self interest.
Man is a predator by nature and what the Left is trying to accomplish goes against this nature. Germany was a thriving Democracy and yet became the worst tyranny known to history. We would do well to learn from history. OH ye Germany is a well respected member of Europe now and democratic and civilized. Can this picture of Europe change, You bet it can.
written by GABE1, March 16, 2011
What should Israel offer to the Arab world as an opener and how do you envision the Arabs reacting.
Lets flesh out the detail as that is where the devil is.
written by GABE1, March 17, 2011
Where has the business been until now and I must point out that none of the Arab pledges EVEN to the Palestinians has been honoured so why would the Arab States come to the front now.
The EU is already pouring millions into the PA and what has been accomplished.
Now to Tachlis- Where will the trillions of dollars come from. How many trillions of Dollars will it take. Why is Saudi Arabia, The Gulf States , Iraq , Iran and Libya unstable with all the riches coming in from Oil money.Is there poverty and unemployment there? What is the unrest in Bahrain all about other than a Shiite majority being rules by a Sunni monarchy minority.
If we are to sink money into a hole lets at least understand that hole and whether it even has a bottom.
Again let me restate that I wish you luck. G-d knows we need peace as far as Israel is concerned and that peace will only come through a stable and democratic Middle East.
Your theories will not and cannot work as there is no will by Humankind to help its fellow man past the point of profit. Again this is not racist or anything else other than Human nature. I may not agree with it but it is what it is.
written by GABE1, March 20, 2011
I am not sure what you are smoking but all that mumbo jumbo made be dizzy from shaking my head in disbelief. DO YOU REALLY BELIEVE IN WHAT YOU ARE THINKING OR is that just a show for your "friends" who are stuck in never never land.
You have not heard a word that I nor the rest of humanity has said over the last 6-10 thousands of years or even in the last 60 years. Even your "image of God " reference is nothing short of platitude.
If I brought your ideas up at any chamber of commerce meeting or in private with people that have money and pull, I WOULD BE LAUGHED OUT OF THAT ROOM AND I just hate being characterized as a stupidly naive person (polite version).
On a final note. Why would anyone pour money into a backwater illiterate economy with no economy to speak off other than exporting radical Islam and terror. I prefer investing in South America where poverty is just as acute,or in Africa where poverty and unemployment is even worse and how about Asia?
These places are rather peaceful and do not export they internal feuds and do not demonize other people and frankly do not demand a silver spoon as do Arabs.
written by GABE1, March 20, 2011
I have analyzed your solution, if it can be even called a solution and it mimics parts of the Marx/Engels worldview with the equality part (Your "good paying jobs" for the whole Arab world). You are even skipping that "any jobs" phase and are going for the jugular. That is not a solution.That my friend is UTOPIA and as far as I know NO ONE on this universe has been able to attain it.
You are even dropping the pretense of self help and expects humankind (especially the wealthy ones) to just endow the "poor" Arabs with instant UTOPIA. I am not sure in what world you are living in , but in mine you have to work very hard to accomplish it and in some parts of the world this is simply a pipe dream. I did give you examples.
I am still not certain or even understand those 22 Iran analogies. Are you saying that unless we succomb to Arab blackmail we may have 22 extremist states spending their money on weapons instead of helping their people? And we may have 22 extremist states on our doorstep instead of the 22 sleeper extremist states we now have. Wow a hell of a choice you are presenting. All this for a minimal cost of how many trillions? Wow, out of the box thinking. I even remember another time and another blackmail that was in fact consumated and later on was paid for again with the blood of 22 million victims. Wow what a bargain this would be when you only consider those trillions of dollars.
Whenever you accomplish the impossible, please do call me after the fact and daydreams do not impress me. How long have you been working on this? Other than an interview, what other accomplishments can I read or hear about. Please point me to a source!!!!
PS In my days I attended meetings upon meetings and found that most of them were a colossal waste of time but as far as meetings go they were very self satisfying especially when my ego was massaged by others.
written by Velvel, March 21, 2011
Failed utopian experiments have convinced all students of history that a few evil people can do a helluva lot of horrible harm (Inquisition, Crusaders, Stalin and friends, Hitler and friends, Pol Pot and friends, and a long list of other nightmares). But not all politicians are so evil (Washington, Lincoln, Mandela, - dreamers all!). So my math also says that a few good men can do a helluva lot of otherwise unpredicted good.
These are the exceptions, in the right place at the right time with enough right colleagues, resources and ideas right for their times. They remain skeptical but not paralyzed. Their doubts are outweighed by the necessity to act and the possibilities of success. With popular approval and minimal active government participation, the change begins. The larger numbers of professional politicians follow the new direction. Ask Bill Gates and a few others who see their wealth and power as, in part, a means to do idealistic, even altruistic projects. It is certainly far from stereotypic greedy capitalism. Ask any long-term, successful small businessperson how much good will towards employees and customers, as opposed to greed, has enabled him to succeed for so long. Remember win-win?
This blog is not ideology about changing mankind. It is rooted in reality and in common sense. It is about this moment with these players, rich and poor, in this part of the world. This may be a time when the vital economic self-interests of our fellow men and women in the Middle East, and that of most of the people with real influence there, are more similar than they have ever been. We see:
•Iran drumbeats sound unpleasantly in everyone’s ears in the region and in echoes even farther away than the reach of deadly delivery systems.
•Radical religious forces state daily that their theological ends justify any and all amoral means to change the entire world, and do all in their power to stir all to join in.
•Our global economic interdependence grows quickly on our flat earth, giving fiscal and monetary disruptions widespread consequences.
•The vision of relative prosperity and comfort enjoyed by others is plain to see electronically and even in person by vast numbers of everyday people with no prospects for their families but uncertain struggles for sheer necessities.
I betcha that among those in the Middle East with the most wealth and power, many are now doing the math on these and related current forces and concluding that something’s gotta give. If they look only at last year’s financial statements and macroeconomic numbers, they probably doubt that they see what their futures may hold. The wisest among them with self-interest alone will re-mold their strategies to diminish the influence of extremists by improving the lot of everyday people in their region. They can do so most effectively by enabling many more people in the Middle East to earn livelihoods with dignity, hope and good purpose, to thereby enjoy and improve their lives and that of their families, without having to harm others.
What is our correspondent Gabe for? I’m not sure. Is it simply “nothing helps”? My grandmother used to say this about a cousin who would not stop a bad habit or a fever that inevitably went away in any case. Our world has more dangerous maladies. We have real danger, and maybe opportunity that is just as real. Let’s look clearly at today and tomorrow in the Middle East, and speak about how we can get a critical mass of influence and wealth to reduce the danger. This is not only about people talking on the web. Its about thoughtful, step-by-step ideas that may take root and produce. They should be nourished and developed.
written by GABE1, March 21, 2011
Some problems are not fixable or are seen as problems by people with rose coloured glasses and are not problems at all.
What problems did Washington, Lincoln and Mandela fix and how were they dreamers or visionaries in any sense of the word.
I have already told Nissim how we can fix the problems of the Middle East but obviously this does not fit into the dreams that you harbour so why even acknowledge it and just say "nothing helps" is my answer.
I would ask that if such wealth distribution was possible where in the world do you think it would be most beneficial? I believe that the Arab world has that wealth distribution potential from within. I do not for one second believe that that will do it. But if you dream it enough who know, maybe a miracle will occur a la Velvel.
written by GABE1, March 22, 2011
I do have an aversion to third parties answering on behalf of others. Velvel is talking in terms of wealth distribution in clear terms.
Let us make a wager and I say that in the next 10 years there will not be any change in the Middle East from the past 50 years. History and change do not turn on a dime dream as we may in technicolour. As an accountant ,I come in contact with a lot of wealthy people as well as mom and pop enterprises. Some of my employers have been in the Fortune 500 categories such as American Standard, Hawker Siddely and Garrard as well as well known builders in the Canadian market whose owners had a net worth of close to a billion dollars.
I know intimately the business mind and business psyche probably as well as anyone around.
Both you and Velvel are dreamers with rose coloured glasses without a shred of realism.
I asked you how long you have been at this dream and whether you have been able to sell this snake oil to anyone yet, Yes I heard about the meetings but show me any concrete accomplishment.
Until and unless the economy can outpace the population growth, not enough jobs (of any quality) can be generated to accomodate that growth. NO ONE in his/her right mind will invest in an unstable region where the main export is terror and where there is only a primitive economy operating. We already have a SHNORER economy operating in Gaza with so called jobs created by UNWRA.
You keep bombarding me with sound bites that I do not see yet on the horizon. THERE IS NOTHING NEW ON THE TABLE. We don't even know who the new players will be and what their agenda is.
People are actually starving in Africa and being murdered in Arab countries and you believe that the Arabs deserve good paying jobs so that they can be peace loving people.
WHAT pure unadulterated nonsense that you and Velvel are spouting. When in Poland I heard these speeches in various shades for 13 years and look where the communist world is now. Everyone had a job and no one starved and some even became wealthy until they were executed. The government called it Democracy and even held elections.
written by GABE1, March 23, 2011
Jordan stretches to sea in online map by Egypt's largest airline, though it continues to fly to Israel
written by GABE1, March 24, 2011
Elaraby "asked Israel to exercise self restraint and warned it against rushing into a military operation in Gaza".
Winds of change, you call it. I prefer the peace we have now than your rose colored solutions
written by GABE1, April 03, 2011
Police said some 65 people were wounded. They said the attackers struck during an annual ceremony for the Sufi saint to whom the shrine is dedicated. (Reuters)



The business community is in it for itself and I have great doubts that it will enter into an area that is so full of uncertainties.
We have to allow the "revolts" to play its course and see where it leads. If it leads to more Islamist radicalization than we must abandon it with haste and if they truly want a better life than we, through our governments must support it both financially and morally.
It is still too early to take any actions until the dust settles.
We will know soon enough what this New Middle East looks like or is capable off.